Warning: This article contains spoilers for A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder.
Summary
A Good Girl’s Guide to Murderhas multiple villain twists, butone of them hits much harder after Prime Video’s 2024 fantasy romance show,My Lady Jane. A Good Girl’s Guide to MurderseesEmma Myers' heroineinvestigating the death of high school student Andie Bell, five years after the case is closed. Pip doesn’t believe that Andie’s boyfriend at the time was the one who killed her — andA Good Girl’s Guide to Murder’s endingproves her right.
Pip discovers that there are layers to Andie’s death, resulting in multiple reveals at the end of season 1. While Andie’s sister, Becca, is the person who sealed Andie’s fate, there are multiple suspects with something to hide. One of them is Max Hastings, who wasn’t directly involved in Andie’s demise. However, his history of sexual assault is uncovered through Pip’s investigation, and it could serve as the centralfocus ofA Good Girl’s Guide to Murderseason 2. Max is played by Henry Ashton, andafterMy Lady Jane, this villain twist feels even more surprising.

A Good Girl’s Guide To Murder’s 8 Biggest Unanswered Questions & Mysteries
Netflix’s A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder wraps up the big mysteries while leaving some questions unanswered, providing directions for Season 2.
Henry Ashton’s A Good Girl’s Guide To Murder Villain Is A Far Cry From His My Lady Jane Character
The Netflix Series' Max Hastings Reveal Shows The Actor’s Range
Ashton plays Lord Stan Dudley inMy Lady Jane,which currently boasts 94% onRotten Tomatoes. And while Stan starts off as a bit of a jerk, he quickly becomes a lovable hero. Stan is probably one of the most beloved characters from Prime Video’s romance show, and Ashton’s performance is largely responsible for that. It’s strange to see Ashton take on a villain role right after, asMax Hastings is a far cry from hisMy Lady Janecharacter.This arguably makesA Good Girl’s Guide to Murder’s twist hit even harder.
While he leans into charm and humor inMy Lady Jane,he explores a darker and less likable personality inA Good Girl’s Guide to Murder.

The shift in characters also shows Ashton’s range as an actor, allowing him to flex different muscles. While he leans into charm and humor inMy Lady Jane,he explores a darker and less likable personality inA Good Girl’s Guide to Murder.And Ashton will switch things up again with his next TV role, which is another big departure from his previous characters.
Henry Ashton’s Next TV Show Character Is Another Big Departure From His 2024 Roles
He’ll Play Daeron Targaryen In A Knight Of The Seven Kingdoms
Ashton’s next TV character will be Daeron Targaryenin HBO’sGame of ThronesspinoffA Knight of the Seven Kingdoms.This role will likely catapult the actor to even greater levels of fame, and it will allow him to explore the middle ground between Stan Dudley and Max Hastings. In George R.R. Martin’s source material, Daeron is described as a drunk with some notable Targaryen gifts. He isn’t a villain, but he isn’t exactly a fan-favorite character either. Needless to say, the show will mark another big jump for Ashton afterA Good Girl’s Guide to Murder.
A Knight of the Seven Kingdomsis currently expected to premiere in late 2025.

A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder
Cast
Pip Fitz-Amobi, a determined young investigator, is set on uncovering the truth behind schoolgirl Andie Bell’s murder five years prior. Sal Singh, Andie’s boyfriend, confessed before his own death, but Pip doesn’t believe he’s guilty. Teaming up with Sal’s brother Ravi, she dives into a web of secrets to find the real killer.