Netflix’sAmerican Primevalhas quickly become one of the streamer’s most successful Western shows of all time. In fact, following its release,American Primevalsoared to the top of Netflix’s charts, proving it to be a massive success with audiences. Whilecritics were more divided on the merits ofAmerican Primeval, its success with audiences proves that the Western genre is a worthwhile area for the streaming service to continue to invest in, especially considering Netflix has finally proven it can compete with Taylor Sheridan’s franchise in the short term.
American Primevalfollows several different groups as they try to travel through Utah or attempt to take control of the land duringthe real-life Utah War. The series exposes the brutality of the time period and makes it very clear that each of the parties is willing to go to extremes to get what they want. By theending ofAmerican Primeval, many of the characters are not left standing, but those who are have very interesting stories left to tell and some are even based on real historical figures.

3American Primeval Season 2 Could Happen & Continue Sara’s Story In California
Sara’s Story Was One Of The Show’s Best
One of the best options forAmerican Primevalto move forward its story would be to continue to follow Sara’s journey to California. Throughout the entirety of the series, Sara and her son Devin had planned to go to Crooks Springs in order to find her husband. However, when the two of them, along with Two Moons, reached the outskirts of the town, they decided to keep traveling west. It leaves their fate unclear after that decision, butAmerican Primevalseason 2 could easily pick that story back up, given that the journey to California could continue to be dangerous.
American Primeval’s interesting historical setting means that there are a lot of historical events that the trio could find themselves wrapped up in as they make their way west.

Overall,Sara, Devin, and Two Moons were some of the best charactersand the story was framed around them from the beginning, so it would make complete sense for season 2 to either continue their journey or show what happens next once they reach California.American Primeval’s interesting historical setting means that there are a lot of historical events that the trio could find themselves wrapped up in as they make their way west. Likewise, following the death of Isaac Reed, audiences would likely be invested in seeing how Sara grieves for him but ultimately comes out stronger.
2An American Primeval Prequel With Taylor Kitsch’s Isaac Reed
Isaac Reed Became A Fan Favorite Character, So A Prequel Would Be Great
In one ofAmerican Primeval’s most shocking moments,Taylor Kitsch’s character Isaac Reed sacrifices himself to save Sarashortly after the two finally admit to having feelings for each other. Over the course of the show, Isaac played a major role in Sara and her group’s survival because he had the most experience living in that area. Despite his rough exterior, Isaac was actually one of the kinder and wiser characters in the series, resulting in him becoming a fan favorite. Because Isaac ultimately died, another season focusing on him would have to be a prequel.
Netflix’s New Global Hit Western Series Is A Reminder To Watch Emily Blunt’s Forgotten Show On Prime Video With 84% On RT
Following American Primeval’s success, Prime has another great Western show starring Emily Blunt that is highly rated and well worth a watch.
Out of all the options for another season ofAmerican Primeval, anIsaac Reed prequel has actually garnered the most support so far. In fact,American Primeval’s creator, Peter Berg, has stated that if the show continued, anIsaac Reed spinoff would be Berg’s first choice. There is definitely more that a spinoff could explore, especially considering that much of Isaac’s past was only hinted at. Isaac is portrayed as very knowledgeable about the area and has guided people across it before, so showing more of that could be interesting. Likewise, the season could explore more about Isaac’s family.
1An American Primeval Sequel Spinoff Has Lots Of Potential
The Series Could Explore The History Of The American West More
American Primevaldoes not pull its punches when it comes to portraying the brutality of the American West at that time, and there are certainly other real events that the series could explore through fictional characters. However, one of the most interesting characters that anAmerican Primevalsequel spinoff could focus on is actually one of the real historical figures: Jim Bridger. While he appeared throughoutAmerican Primeval,Bridger actually felt underutilized due to the massive role that he played in real life.
Because Jim Bridger is woven through many of the stories of the American West, he would be the perfect character to center a sequel series around. The series would be able to explore both his own real adventures and would be able to incorporate the stories of fictional characters in the same way that the first season ofAmerican Primevaldid. Using Bridger as a starting point and central character,American Primevalwould be able to expand outwards from there and tell a lot of interesting, historically based stories that would be able to continue Netflix’s Western success.