American Idolseason 23 has proven that with new judge Carrie Underwood in play, it could be time for judges Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie to take a step back, and with that,here are my picks for the next set of judgesto appear on the series.American Idolseason 23has been fascinating thus far, but there’s been a bit of resistance from long-time viewers who just don’t feel the show tugging at their heartstrings anymore.American Idolhas long been one of the most heartwarming talent competitions on the air, but that came from a specific formula.
WhileAmerican Idolstill shows heartwarming stories, there’s something missing from the series in the last few seasons as the judges' panel has been shaken up. After the departure of Katy Perry at the end ofAmerican Idolseason 22, it was clear there was something left to be desired working as anIdoljudge. Katy was replaced by Carrie,the winner ofAmerican Idolseason 4, andhas been someone that viewers are still growing to understandafter the first few episodes. With Luke and Lionel still part of the show, there’s a lot of change that could come.
I think bringing American Idol alumni into the judging panel could be something that helps shake up the show.
American Idol Season 24 Needs More Idol-Centric Judges
They Have A Ton Of Alumni At Their Disposal
AsAmerican Idolhas been on the air for nearly two decades,the series has been a major cultural phenomenon, but it doesn’t always learn from its mistakes. While the judges on the revamped version of the series that debuted in 2018 have remained nearly the same for the duration, bringing in talent like Luke, Lionel, and Katy was an interesting move when revitalizing a series that creates superstars.With Carrie in the mix now, it feels more vital than ever to bring otherAmerican Idolalumni into the judging space, creating camaraderie with the new performers.
20 Best Reality TV Shows Right Now
Reality TV is more popular than ever. With so many to choose from, here are some of the best reality TV shows to stream or watch right now.
AsAmerican Idolhas a repository of starsthat they’ve given a platform, it’s possible that winners, contestants and even those who merely auditioned and found stardom another way could be an asset to the series. Judging the competitors and bringing their own takes to the table,I think bringingAmerican Idolalumni into the judging panelcould be something that helps shake up the show. While things to stay true to the roots ofAmerican Idol’svalues, new judges that stem from the series could be an interesting ploy.
American Idol Should Replace Lionel Richie With Adam Lambert
He’s Become An Incredible Performer
I thinkAmerican Idol’sjudge Lionel has been incredible, and as one of the world’s biggest superstars, he’s brought immeasurable value to the show. While I love Lionel, I think it’s time to bring new blood to the judging panel, and with an Idol-centric idea behind it, I thinkAdam Lambert could be a fun replacement. Adam, who competed onAmerican Idolseason 8, didn’t win the show, but has gone on to become a superstar in his own right. His ability to bend genres is incredible, andhe’d be able to pass on great advice to the contestants.
American Idol Should Replace Luke Bryan With Jennifer Hudson
She’s A Multi-Faceted Talent
AlthoughJennifer Hudson came in seventh place duringAmerican Idolseason 3, she’s gone on to have a massive career that includes winning the EGOT and hosting her own talkshow. BringingJenniferin to replace Luke, who’s of asimilar country background to Carrie, could create more diversity in the panel, allow a judge into the space who doesn’t have the perfect Idol success story, and open up more opportunities for the contestants to feel comfortable failing. Jennifer would be an incredible pick forAmerican Idolseason 24, and could round out a fascinating panel of new Idol-centric judges.
