Warning: SPOILERS for Doctor Odyssey episode 9.Doctor Odysseyfinally made its midseason return, but episode 9 highlights the medical drama’s big characterization problem. Joshua Jackson leads theDoctor Odysseycast of charactersas Dr. Max Bankman, the new doctor aboardThe Odysseyfollowing a near-death experience. Joining him on the ship captained by Robert Massey (Don Johnson) are two nurses, Tristan Silva (Sean Teale) and Avery Morgan (Phillipa Soo). Though Avery initially held a grudge against Max due to her ambitious goal of becomingThe Odyssey’s doctor, her drive now seems more like a fluke.
While characters like Max and Captain Massey have remained fundamentally the same since the series began, others have had dramatic, and at times baffling, shifts in their personality, with none as egregious as Avery. SinceDoctor Odysseyseason 2remains unconfirmed, whatever the maritime procedural chooses to do with its ensemble cast in the pilot season could very well be the last form these characters ever take. It’s natural for characters to grow and develop as a new show finds its identity, butDoctor Odysseyis potentially ruining Avery and, by extension, the show at large.
Avery’s Character Can’t Make Up Her Mind In Doctor Odyssey Episode 9
It’s Difficult To Pin Down What She Actually Wants
The early episodes ofDoctor Odysseypainted Avery as a headstrong but caring, ambitious but stubborn, intelligent but opportunistic character. It seemed as if the only woman in the main cast would at least have a nuanced personality, but her interesting dichotomies fade more and more with each episode. As a result of Avery, Tristan, and Max’s love triangleromance inDoctor Odyssey, Avery unexpectedly becomes pregnant at the same time she was offered a scholarship to med school.Doctor Odysseyepisode 9 barely touches on Avery’s dilemma, however, instead opting for a hypocritical jealousy storyline.
I’ve Suddenly Lost Interest In 9-1-1 & Doctor Odyssey’s Crossover After Learning About This 1 Detail
ABC’s new medical drama is crossing paths with its long-running procedural, but the 9-1-1 and Doctor Odyssey crossover already has a hurdle to cross.
Doctor Odysseyimplied Max is the father of Avery’s baby, but there’s still no official confirmation. Avery is harsh with Max at the top of the episode, demanding space and insisting that she has no expectations of him. Yet, after Dr. Brooke Lane (Adrianne Palicki) flirts with Max, Avery inexplicably becomes upset and confronts him about his fickleness. Ironically,no character is more capricious than Avery inDoctor Odyssey, as she either doesn’t want what she has, wants what she can’t have, or insists she doesn’t know what she wants at all while complaining if an opportunity passes her by.
How Avery’s Indecisiveness Could Ruin Her Character & Doctor Odyssey
She’s Just A Vessel For Drama
By making Avery such an inconsistent character, all of her best traits seem inconsequential and temporary at best. TheAvery inDoctor Odysseyepisode 9 feels unidentifiable compared to Avery from episode 1, which makes her"one step forward, two steps back"routine all the more frustrating. As a Nurse Practitioner with big dreams, Avery could be an incredibly compelling character. Unfortunately, Avery’s biggest storylines end up playing second fiddle to the volatile relationship she has with Max, diluting her into nothing more than a hot-and-cold love interest rather than a clear protagonist with independent arcs and motivations.
Sean Teale
Tristan Silva
On a broader scale, Avery’s indecision risks squandering the upbeat, campy tone ofDoctor Odyssey’s luxury cruise ship. The procedural may be billed as a drama, butDoctor Odyssey’s ridiculous theme weeksand exaggerated dialogue veer into soap opera territory (which isn’t a bad thing). In a world where weighty dramas are a dime a dozen, there’s something to be said about having a little fun. Instead of making Avery an ill-defined character in a world that takes itself too seriously,Doctor Odysseyshould lean into its camp factor and keep its main characters on level footing.
