TheBachelorfranchise is expected to announce the identity ofThe Golden Bachelorany day now,and I’m convinced that Mark Anderson is a better choice than Pascal Ibgui. The franchise is known for casting past contestants as leads of their unscripted dating shows, and all the front-runners for the role of the spin-off’s next lead appeared inThe Golden Bacheloretteseason 1. 58-year-old Mark Anderson made his television premiere alongside his daughter, Kelsey Anderson, onThe Bachelor28, and was then cast as a contestant for 61-year-old Joan Vassos' heart. 69-year-old Pascal made his debut onThe Golden Bachelorette.

Both men have a lot to recommend them, but, unless there’s a double-lead season, only one man will be cast asThe Golden Bachelor.Since appearing onThe Bachelorseason 28,Mark was the clear favorite to lead his own season ofThe Bachelorspin-off. I even speculated that he was only cast inThe Golden Bacheloretteseason 1 to groom him for the role. While he still remained the favorite, Pascal came in from behind to give Mark a run for his money. Though I think Pascal is entertaining, I’m convinced Mark should leadThe Golden Bachelorseason 2.

a montage of Gerry Turner from the golden bachelor in side by side images

“Something Missing”

After appearing briefly onThe Bachelorseason 28, Mark left a big impression, and he was soon cast as a contestant on the inaugural season ofThe Golden Bachelorette. He wasone of 24 singleGoldenmen who had traveled from all over the country to date Joan, who had made her television debut as a contestant onThe Golden Bachelorseason 1. On the opening night of Joan’s season, she stood outside the iconicBachelormansion, greeting her men in a fleet of limousines.

20 Best Reality TV Dating Shows

Reality TV dating has become a complex and nuanced part of the genre, welcoming all different types of dating shows. Here are the 20 best!

When Mark stepped out of the limousine on the opening night ofThe Golden Bacheloretteseason 1, Joan knew exactly who he was. She recognized him from his brief appearance onThe Bachelorseason 28, and I believe she was genuinely excited about the chance to date the retired Army veteran. Joan and Mark had a lot in common, asthey were both widowers who had deeply loved their late spouses. Joan was married to John Vassos for 32 years before he passed away in 2021, whileMark was married to Denise Andersonfor 18 years before she died in 2018.

The Golden Bachelorette’s Pascal Igbui looking upset with his hands over his face in one photo

Though Joan and Mark shared a sense of profound loss, I never saw evidence that they connected on a more romantic level.

Though Joan seemed to like Mark well enough, she liked other men more, like60-year-old Chock Chapple and 61-year-old Jordan Heller. Just as it started to seem like Joan forgot Mark was there, she gave him a highly coveted one-on-one date. After a painfully awkward voyage on a luxury yacht, Joan went to theBachelormansion unannounced, took Mark aside, and told him that there was “something missing” between them, and sent him home before that night’s rose ceremony.

The golden Bachelorette Mark Anderson is situated in front of a group shot of The Golden Bachelor women.

Pascal Is Too Much Drama

Way Too High Maintenance

Pascal traveled to theBachelormansion from his home in Chicago, Illinois, where he runs a luxury beauty salon. The divorced father of two was looking for love, and excited about meeting Joan. The witty, charming Pascal immediately became a fan favorite,but he brought a lot of baggage and drama. I think it’s bizarre that a man his age can’t wash or iron his own clothes. He needed the othermen ofThe Golden Bacheloretteseason 1to do everything for him. Though it was mildly amusing, Pascal is too much of a diva to beThe Golden Bachelor.

Pascal Devastated Joan

Ripped Joan’s Heart Out On National Television

All seemed well when Pascal made it to Joan’s final three, but disaster struck during their overnight date. WhileThe Golden Bacheloretteseason 1couple were participating in a symbolic bonding ceremony, Pascal completely freaked out. Though the bonding ritual was only symbolic, it made Pascal question his feelings for Joan. In a scene posted to YouTube byBachelor Nation, a panickedPascaltold Joan that he couldn’t love her, saw her as more of a friend, and eliminated himself from the show.

Mark Is More Charismatic Than Pascal

While Pascal Is Much Funnier

Mark and Pascal have different strengths and weaknesses that they bring to the table, and either man would make a goodBachelorlead. The witty, charming Pascal is legitimately hilarious and kept the other men in stitches duringThe Golden Bacheloretteseason 1.The fact that things didn’t work out between him and Joan shouldn’t keep him from getting the role as the next lead, especially sinceJoan ended up with the man of her dreams in Chock. I think casting Pascal would giveThe Golden Bachelora fun, international flavor, and the season could even travel to Paris, France.

While Pascal would be an entertaining choice, I still feel strongly that Mark would make a better romantic lead.

The Golden Bachelor TV Poster

Pascal may be charming and funny, but Mark just emits that main character energy that aBachelorNation lead needs. Mark may be soft-spoken, but his quiet strength creates an aura of mystery that audiences just can’t get enough of. There’s a reason that Mark’s brief screen time duringThe Bachelorseason 28had such staying power. The bottom line is thatMark just has the kind of charisma that can’t be taught, bought, or manufactured. There’s a deep sense of authenticity to Mark, as well as the ability to be vulnerable. He may not have been the right man for Joan, but he should be the nextThe Golden Bachelor.

58 years old

Widowed, 5 children

69 years old

Divorced, 2 children

Luxury salon owner

The Golden Bachelor

Cast

The Bachelor returns to TV with The Golden Bachelor, a romantic reality competition series created for ABC. The show will focus on an older generation of hopefuls, with one senior male hoping to court and win the heart of one of several older female contestants.