Supermanis often stated to be the greatest hero in the DC Universe. No matter how hopeless a situation seems, Superman is always there as a beacon of hope. But plenty of creators have explored stories where Superman is evil for one reason or another. After all this time, “evil Superman” is a pretty tired trope, and comic book writer Grant Morrison has made it clear that they’re tired of it.
Characters like Superman have been around for nearly a hundred years. At this point, it’s perfectly normal for comic book creators to want to try something different with the Man of Steel. Considering Superman is one of the greatest heroes in comics, turning him evilseemed like an easy direction to explore, especially in theInjusticeuniverse.
Creators love to come back to the idea of an evil Superman time and time again.Injusticeran for years simply by focusing on Superman as a tyrannical dictator. As much as DC’s creatorsseem to love exploring an evil Superman, Morrison just isn’t a fan of the idea.
Injustice Superman Is Everything Superman Shouldn’t Be
Injustice: Gods Among Us#1 by Tom Taylor, Jheremy Raapack, Andrew Elder, and Wes Abbott
During an interview withCBR, Morrison explained that they believe Superman turning tyrannical due to tragedy is a completely ridiculous idea. Most writers try to find a way to “break” Superman to make these stories work, putting Superman through unimaginable tragedy. The biggest example of this “breaking” is in the infamousInjusticeuniverse, whereSuperman is tricked into murdering Lois Lane, thereby killing his unborn baby, and obliterating Metropolis with a nuclear bomb. These events pushedSuperman into becoming a dictator,as he immediately tried to take over the world in response.
Batman Will Never Admit That He & Injustice’s Evil Superman Are The Same
Batman and Superman fought for years in the Injustice universe, but a long-overlooked conclusion might just prove that Batman agreed with Superman.
Superman’s breakdown led to a decade-long war betweenBatman and Superman for control of the planet. This storyline is often heavily criticized due to the wild mischaracterization of the majority of its cast, the most prominent being Superman and Wonder Woman. The biggest issue withInjusticeis the idea that Superman isn’t someone who would be able to handle grief. As Morrison states: “My mum and dad died, and I didn’t become a tyrant.” Superman ismeant to be everything humanity can be and more, so it’s hard to bellieve that he can’t handle one tragedy without turning evil.
Superman’s Character Doesn’t Work If He’s Evil
Making Superman Evil Means He Isn’t Superman Anymore
That’s always been the problem with storiesthat try to focus on an evil Superman. The simple fact is that if it the character were really Superman, then he wouldn’t be evil, regardless of the situation. Superman would never respond to tragedy by trying to impose his will on Earth and getting into a bloody war with his former friends. He might take a step back from being a superhero, orhe might abandon the job entirely, as he did in Mark Waid and Alex Ross’Kingdom Come. But he would never decide to become a maniac and attempt to take over the world.
The real Superman simply wouldn’t be evil for any reason.
The majority of Evil Superman trope characters tend to fall flat with their motivation because the real Superman simply wouldn’t be evil for any reason. Homelander fromThe Boysis evil simply because he’s mostly gas-lit into being evil; there isn’t much motivation there. DC characters like Ultraman exist purely to be evil reflections of Superman without any tangible reason.Superman simply would not become a villain, no matter the situation, and every story that tries to force him into that role usually ends up being a bit ridiculous, as Morrison points out.
DC Icon Grant Morrison Will Never Understand How “Evil Superman” Works
Superman Would Never Become a Tyrant for Any Reason
It’s expected that after eighty-plus years of Supermab stories, people might want to take this amazing symbol of hope and see what he would be like as a tyrannical force throughout the world. It makes sense to take Superman in that direction after all these decades, but just because it makes sense doesn’t mean it’s a good idea. Morrison also states that they see howSuperman could work as the eternal patriarchal figurelooming over society, but that depicting Superman like this would be a mistake. It goes against everything Superman was originally created for and doesn’t even say anything interesting about his character.
Among DC fans, Grant Morrison is perhaps best known for their extended run on various Batman titles, where he co-created Damian Wayne, as well as their work with Frank Quitely onAll-Star Superman, widely considered one of the best Superman stories of all time.
Superman is meant to be an inversion of the idea that absolute power corrupts absolutely. Superman is a fantasy that there could be a man with unlimited power who then uses that unlimited power to do good. That’s what makes Superman such a comforting figure: the fantasy that there is someone who could be trusted with all the power in the world. But turning Superman into a dictator who just wants to rule the world is just boring. The trope turnsSupermaninto every other man in world history who has gotten even an ounce of power.
Source:CBR
Superman
The icon who launched the entire world of superheroes, the last son of Krypton escaped his dying world to crash land on Earth and be raised as Clark Kent. The world knows him better as Superman, the Man of Steel, the leader of the Justice League, and the most well-known hero in the DC Comics Universe. Blessed with the powers of a demigod, Kal-El of Krypton fights enemies both small and cosmic in his endless pursuit of truth, justice, and a better tomorrow.
