Sansa Stark star Sophie Turner revealed her conditions for returning to the world of Westeros, but her biggestGame of Thronesseason 9 questions show why another outing wouldn’t work.Game of Thronescame to a close in 2019, finally revealing who wound up on the Iron Throne — and it wasn’t who most viewers expected. Bran Stark becoming the new ruler of the Seven Kingdoms wasn’t the only reasonGame of Thrones’final season was so divisive, and viewers have since discussed the possibility of bringing the show back for another go-round.
HBO’s canceled Jon Snow spinoffwould have shed light on what happened after the events ofGame of Thrones,but according to Kit Harington, it was axed when the creators realized there wasn’t much of a story to tell. When asked if she would ever return to HBO’sGame of Thronesuniverse,Turner gave a hesitant “maybe,“saying the same cast and crew would need to be present for her to consider it. She admitted that she has questions about what’s next for Sansa. However,those questions make a good case for whyGame of Thronesseason 9 shouldn’t happen.
Sophie Turner’s Game Of Thrones Season 9 Questions Show Why It Won’t Work
A Follow-Up Would Repeat The Original HBO Series
When asked about returning to the world ofGame of Thrones,Turner toldVarietythat she wonders about what’s next for Sansa Stark after season 8. “Where would she be five years later, what would she be doing?” Turner said. “Would she still be queen in the North? Would she be a good ruler? Would there be some other kind of terrible war that’s happened?” These are all fair questions, as there’s little doubt that Sansa will face more challenges as a leader in Westeros. However, Turner’s questions highlight a problem with actually answering them.
There isn’t much left to explore when it comes to power in Westeros, and that would make season 9 feel pointless.
IfGame of Thronesseason 9 were to happen — and bring back most of the former cast — it would likely begin a new war for power. Turner directly alludes to this, as it’s the most obvious place for aGame of Thronessequel to go. Unfortunately,this would repeat the original HBO series' premise, making it feel stale and unoriginal. There isn’t much left to explore when it comes to power in Westeros, and that would make season 9 feel pointless. Additionally, for characters like Sansa Stark, there’s nowhere else to go without regressing.
Returning To Characters Like Sansa Stark Would Undo The Show’s Most Satisfying Endings
It Would Further Harm Game Of Thrones' Legacy
Sansa has one of the most satisfying character arcs inGame of Thrones,and season 8 brings everything together to finally give her a win. Returning to Sansa’s story would likely force her to regress, and it would ruin one of the best endings of the series. The same is true for other characters who end up in positions of power. Players like Brienne, Gendry, and Bronn may not be wearing a crown in the finale, but they’re all in better positions.Their fates are the silver linings ofGame of Thrones’ending, and season 9 would just undo them.
10 Game Of Thrones Characters Who Deserved To Survive Until The Finale
Game of Thrones was notorious for killing off characters, and there are some who could’ve improved the finale if they’d been kept around.
WithGame of Thronesseason 9 likely reversing the best parts of the show’s ending, it would further harm the fantasy series' legacy. Season 8 already left a bad taste in viewers' mouths, and it’d be impossible to undo the final season’s biggest mistakes without rebooting the series.HBO shouldn’t make things worseby returning to the story after the fact. IfGame of Thronesseason 9 were to happen, it shouldn’t follow the leaders of the Seven Kingdoms. It would be better off following characters more removed from the original series and its politics.
Game Of Thrones Season 9 Would Only Work More Removed From The Original Series
Following Arya Stark Or Jon Snow Would Work Better
The only wayGame of Thronesseason 9 could work without further hurting the original ending is to be removed from the original series.Following characters like Arya Stark or Jon Snow would be more effective, as neither of them are in the Seven Kingdoms — or involved in their power struggles — any longer. It’s hard to say what Jon’s story could be about, as the White Walkers are no longer a threat. However, a new enemy beyond the Wall sounds more intriguing than another fight for the now non-existent Iron Throne.
This would be more fresh and exciting than Turner’s vision ofGame of Thronesseason 9, as it wouldn’t dredge up old narratives and undo hard-won victories.
Arya is probably the strongest contender to lead a spinoff or sequel, as she leaves to find out “what’s west of Westeros” at theend ofGame of Thrones.Exploring what she finds would be all-new territory for the HBO franchise,and it would allow it to introduce new characters, locations, and storylines going forward. This would be more fresh and exciting than Turner’s vision ofGame of Thronesseason 9, as it wouldn’t dredge up old narratives and undo hard-won victories.
Game of Thrones
Game of Thrones is a multimedia franchise created by George R.R. Martin. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire is the basis for the award-winning HBO series Game of Thrones, which lasted for eight seasons. After the incredibly divisive final season of Game of Thrones, the series was followed up by the prequel series House of the Dragon, which also received critical acclaim.
